Kitchen Sink Ice Cream Treat

Kitchen Sink Ice Cream is the ultimate way to turn whatever treats you have on hand into a rich and indulgent dessert night. This customizable recipe is endlessly fun and a total crowd-pleaser because you can pack every scoop with different flavors and textures. I have made this for get-togethers when everyone wanted something different and trust me it always gets rave reviews and big smiles from kids and grown-ups alike

Ingredients

• Heavy cream: the base for a creamy texture Choose high-quality cream for the richest flavor
• Whole milk: keeps the ice cream scoopable and soft Using fresh milk really makes a difference
• White sugar: adds sweetness and stabilizes the ice cream Opt for fine granulated sugar so it blends in smooth
• Kosher salt: brightens all the flavors Choose flaky kosher salt for a clean taste without bitterness
• Vanilla extract: the key for depth and classic ice cream aroma Pure vanilla works best for a warm and inviting flavor
• Add-ins: such as chopped cookies nuts toasted coconut chocolate chips toffee bits candies Choose a mix of textures and avoid anything that gets too hard when frozen For cookies or candy bars use freshly chopped pieces so the bits stay chunky and do not dissolve
• Tips for quality: Mix in only dry or well-drained items to avoid icy bits

Step-by-Step Instructions

Make the Ice Cream Base:

Combine heavy cream whole milk white sugar salt and vanilla extract in a large bowl Whisk thoroughly until the sugar is fully dissolved and the mixture feels silky This sets up a smooth clean-flavored base for your add-ins

Churn the Ice Cream:

Pour your creamy mixture into an ice cream maker Churn following your machine instructions until thick like soft serve This stage locks in air for a fluffy texture so do not rush it

Prep the Add-ins:

While your machine churns gather around two cups of your favorite add-ins I like to chop any large pieces into similar sizes so every bite is balanced Dry sticky treats like toffee bits on a paper towel to keep them from clumping

Layer and Combine:

Scoop some churned ice cream into a container Sprinkle liberally with add-ins Continue to layer ice cream and toppings making sure every scoop has a little bit of everything This layering keeps your extras from sinking or collecting just on top

Freeze Until Set:

Seal your container and freeze at least two hours or until the ice cream is firm enough to scoop When serving add even more toppings if you want and dig in for the ultimate treat

Pin it

I love using toasted coconut in mine as it always adds a chewy surprise My kids get so excited choosing mix-ins and there is a bit of competition for who gets the last bite with the most treasures in it

Storage tips

Store Kitchen Sink Ice Cream in an airtight container deep in the freezer to keep it creamy and fresh Press wax paper directly on the surface to prevent ice crystals For the best texture let the container sit out five minutes before scooping After a week add-ins with lots of sugar like candy bars help maintain softness

Pin it

Ingredient substitutions

You can swap heavy cream for coconut cream for a dairy-free twist Whole milk can be replaced with any plant-based milk though the texture will be a bit icy For flavor swap the vanilla for coffee extract almond extract or mint and experiment with seasonal fruit or jam swirls

Serving suggestions

Serve big scoops in cones or bowls top with even more crunchy bits or warm chocolate sauce For a party set up a toppings bar and let everyone customize their own bowls Leftover ice cream makes a decadent milkshake or can be sandwiched between cookies for homemade ice cream sandwiches

Cultural or historical context

This playful ice cream gets its name from the idea of using everything but the kitchen sink which means all sorts of treats are fair game Kitchen Sink Ice Cream is inspired by American-style mix-ins and the fun of customizing store-bought pints at home There is always room for creativity with this recipe and that spirit is what makes it timeless

Frequently Asked Questions

→ Can I use other milk alternatives for this frozen treat?

Yes, substitute coconut milk or oat milk for the whole milk, but texture and creaminess may vary slightly.

→ What are the best add-ins for extra crunch?

Chopped nuts, toffee bits, miniature candies, and crushed cookies all provide great texture and flavor.

→ How do I store leftover frozen dessert?

Keep it in an airtight container in your freezer. Press parchment on top to prevent ice crystals from forming.

→ Can I make this without an ice cream machine?

Yes, simply freeze the mixture in a loaf pan, stirring every half hour for creamy results.

→ How do I prevent add-ins from sinking?

Fold add-ins gently into the churned base before freezing, or layer them as you transfer the mixture to your container.

→ Can I use less sugar?

Reducing sugar is possible, but it may affect the softness and scoopability of the dessert.