Pin
I whipped up this eggnog tiramisu by combining two amazing tastes into one knockout dessert. This wonderful mix of Christmas eggnog and traditional Italian layers turned into my go-to holiday sweet after I came up with it five years back. The ladyfingers soaked in coffee get a special kick from creamy eggnog while the mascarpone mixture feels like fluffy holiday cheer. Whenever I bring this out at gatherings folks are amazed at how these two familiar flavors make something totally unique.
A Delightful Holiday Spin
This eggnog tiramisu grabs all the best parts of the Christmas season. Bold coffee perfectly matches the warm eggnog spices for an amazing balance in each mouthful. My folks start begging for it the minute eggnog shows up in stores and honestly I totally get why.
Easy No-Bake Wonder
Don't let the fancy look trick you this eggnog tiramisu takes just half an hour to put together. You won't need your oven just some time for it to chill. I really like that I can fix it before company comes so I can spend more time with everyone during the holidays. I've even made it two days early and it actually tastes better after sitting.
Mixing the Coffee Blend
The magic of this eggnog tiramisu begins with the soaking liquid. I mix fresh espresso with smooth eggnog to make this awesome syrup that goes into each ladyfinger. The coffee balances the sweetness just right while the eggnog adds that special holiday flavor.
Whipping the Mixture
For the fluffiest filling in this eggnog tiramisu beat your cream until stiff peaks form. Then mix your mascarpone sugar eggnog and a dash of nutmeg. Remember to fold everything together carefully to keep that airy texture we want.
Pin
The Ideal Consistency
This eggnog tiramisu should have a mixture that's super light but still keeps its shape. I sometimes whip it a bit longer if needed. When you dig in you should clearly see each layer promising that great combo of coffee and holiday spices.
Stacking Your Creation
Quickly dunk each ladyfinger in the coffee mix but don't let them get mushy. Put them in your dish then spread the lovely filling on top. Do it all one more time finishing with the filling. I enjoy making small peaks on top with my spatula it looks really nice.
Time to Rest
Stick your dessert in the fridge for at least 6 hours. This sitting time helps all those awesome flavors blend together. The ladyfingers get just soft enough while the filling firms up so you can slice it perfectly.
The Last Sprinkle
Right before serving sprinkle the top with fresh nutmeg. Sometimes I add tiny chocolate shavings too they look like little snowflakes on the creamy top. When you put it on the table the smell is simply amazing.
Save for Later
Have some left? You're in luck! This treat freezes really well. Just wrap single pieces properly they'll stay good for up to 3 months. Though at my place they rarely stick around that long someone always finds them in the freezer.
Pin
Customize It
Don't be afraid to change things up. Adding bourbon to the coffee mix gives it a nice grown-up twist. I sometimes put caramel sauce between layers or sprinkle chocolate bits on top. You can try so many different things.
Worth Noting
While definitely a treat this dessert isn't too sweet. The mascarpone and coffee work perfectly with the rich eggnog. You can try low-fat mascarpone for a lighter version but I usually go with regular for special times.
Great for Gatherings
This dessert really stands out at holiday parties. Seeing how happy people look when they try their first bite makes the wait totally worth it. It's become such a tradition that Christmas wouldn't feel right without it.
The Secret Appeal
The real wonder comes from turning familiar holiday tastes into something fresh and exciting. That mix of smooth filling spiced eggnog and coffee-soaked cookies makes every bite pure happiness. It's both fancy and comforting all wrapped up in one pretty dessert.
Closing Thoughts
This holiday treat mixes Italian tradition with Christmas spirit. Whether you're throwing a big party or just want to make your holidays extra nice it always wows everyone. Try it out and watch it become your family's new Christmas tradition.
Pin
Closing Thoughts
This holiday dessert blends fluffy eggnog cream with coffee-drenched ladyfingers. It's a light, crowd-pleasing option for Christmas celebrations.
Common Recipe Questions
- → Can I prepare it early?
Yep! It actually needs at least 6 hours in the fridge. You can make it 1-2 days before serving.
- → Which eggnog works best?
Any kind, whether from the store or homemade, will do. Just make sure it's fresh and well-blended first.
- → What can I use instead of mascarpone?
While mascarpone is ideal, cream cheese is a simple swap. It won't taste exactly the same, but it'll still be great.
- → How long can I store it?
It stays good for about 4 days in the fridge. Cover it up to keep other smells out.
- → Is it okay to freeze it?
You can, but freezing changes the texture of the mascarpone. Fresh is always better with this dessert.