Pin
Juicy chicken thighs soaked in a flavorful paprika sauce are just right for any summer cookout. Smoky paprika, tender meat, and a hint of sweetness make this a real showstopper right off the grill. Plus, you can have it ready in under an hour. The smell brings me right back to hanging outside on warm evenings, when garlic and paprika scents drift through the whole neighborhood.
I tried this on a whim for a last-minute barbecue, and ever since then, everyone's always hoping for these chicken thighs. It's my family's new go-to, and every bite brings back easy summer kitchen memories.
Effortless Ingredients
- Boneless, skinless chicken thighs: extra juicy and tender, look for high-quality chicken from good sources
- Fresh garlic: boosts the marinade's bold, tasty kick, use whole cloves instead of jarred chopped garlic
- Olive oil: makes the marinade silky and helps everything brown up on the grill, use extra virgin for max flavor
- Black pepper: adds just enough heat, grinding it fresh is always best for flavor
- Salt: brings out all the other tastes, coarse sea salt is the way to go
- Paprika powder (smoked): for that signature smoky color and taste, go for the best Spanish paprika you can find
- Brown sugar: throws in a caramel twist and helps those nice grill marks form, fine crystals work best
- Garlic powder: gives a gentle bite—great if fresh garlic feels too strong
Simple How-To Guide
- Let it rest and serve:
- Let the chicken sit for a few before slicing. That keeps it super juicy. Serve hot and enjoy right away.
- Cook through on indirect heat:
- Shift the chicken to a cooler spot on the grill and cook for eight to ten minutes more. It's done when the thickest part is cooked through and the juices are clear. Double-check it hits about 165°F with a meat thermometer.
- Grill those thighs:
- Sizzle those chicken thighs directly over the hottest part of your grill. Cook each side for right around four minutes till they're nice and golden. Crispy crust outside, juicy inside—just the way you want them.
- Fire up that grill:
- Get the grill good and hot, medium to high. Throw a little oil on the grate so nothing sticks and you get awesome grill marks.
- Soak the chicken in marinade:
- Toss the chicken thighs in a big bowl or zip bag, add a splash of olive oil, throw in chopped garlic, and sprinkle the spice blend over everything. Give it a solid mix so each piece is well-coated. Let it chill in the fridge at least half an hour so the flavors soak in.
- Make the marinade:
- Grab a small bowl and stir together smoked paprika, brown sugar, garlic powder, pepper, and salt. Mix well so it's pretty even. That's how you get the best flavor out of every bite.
Pin
Good to Know
- Packed with protein, so it's great for building muscle and keeping you full
- The smoky paprika and fresh garlic make it super tasty
- You can prep ahead—marinade works overnight too
This always brings back memories of chill backyard barbecues and that awesome summer smell. My favorite part? Watching the paprika marinade sizzle and make the chicken all orangey and beautiful on a heavy cast iron grill. My kids usually snag a piece before I can even get them to the table.
Save It For Later
Once cooked, keep the chicken wrapped tight and it'll last three days in the fridge. Tastes awesome cold for a picnic or buffet too. If you're freezing, let the chicken cool off first then portion it out—defrost overnight in the fridge and zap it in the oven to warm up.
Swap Out Ingredients
If brown sugar's not around, maple syrup works and gets you a whole new layer of sweet, caramel flavor. Turkey steaks taste amazing in the paprika mix—just cook them a bit less. No smoked paprika? Use regular sweet paprika and a pinch of smoked salt instead.
Pin
How to Serve
This chicken goes so well with crisp Mediterranean salads like cucumber-tomato or just a chunk of crusty bread. Roasted potatoes with a dusting of paprika and a little olive oil are always a hit, too. For a bright zing, squeeze some fresh lemon juice on top and toss on some herbs.
Cultural Background
Paprika is a hero spice in Spanish and Hungarian food, giving all kinds of grilled stuff a special kick. In Germany, grilling chicken thighs with paprika is a summer tradition at backyard parties. Garlic plus paprika? Pretty much the classic flavor combo—lots of folks say it reminds them of holidays or family get-togethers.
Common Recipe Questions
- → What kind of paprika should I use for the marinade?
Smoked paprika gives the most intense, smoky taste. Sweet paprika works too if you want it milder.
- → How long does the chicken need to soak in the marinade?
Stick the chicken in the marinade for at least 30 minutes in the fridge. A few hours is even better for more flavor.
- → How do I know when the chicken's cooked through?
It's done when the inside hits 74°C and clear juices come out if you poke it.
- → Can I use the same marinade for other meats?
Definitely. This paprika marinade is great for turkey, pork, or even veggies on the grill.
- → What side dishes go well with grilled chicken legs?
Try crispy potatoes, fresh salad, or some toasted bread. They're all awesome choices.
- → Do I need to leave the skin on the chicken legs?
Nope! The chicken stays juicy and full of flavor, even without the skin.