Pin
I keep coming back to these tangy-spicy grilled chicken thighs when summer hits or when I've got folks over for dinner. What makes these stand out is how that smoky blend crisps up outside and the thighs stay super moist inside every single time.
I threw this together on a whim for a backyard hangout and soon everyone was lining up for seconds and asking what I put in it by the end of the evening.
Delicious Ingredients
- Red pepper flakes: These bring the heat. If you want it milder, use less. Crush 'em up so they mix in better
- Salt: This lifts all the flavors in every bite
- Dried oregano: Adds a hint of earthy herbs. Crush it right before you toss it in for the most flavor
- Granulated garlic or garlic powder: Bumps up the savory vibe. Choose one without salt for better control
- Smoked paprika: Adds that campfire flavor you get at a real BBQ. Spanish kind is classic but use whatever you can find
- Chili powder: Warmth and color go in with this one. A good chili blend makes a difference
- Onion powder: Rounds everything out and adds depth. Use a freshly opened jar for bold flavor
- Brown sugar: Brings that sweet crust and helps balance the hot stuff. Finer sugar sticks better
- Boneless skinless chicken thighs: The star of the show. Get evenly sized ones so they cook the same
Simple Steps
- Let It Rest:
- Move those pieces to a plate and give them five minutes to chill out before you dig in. This is how you keep all those tasty juices inside
- Fire Up The Grill:
- Turn your grill to medium. Scrub and oil it a bit. Toss on your chicken and close the lid. Grill about six to eight minutes per side. Check for solid grill marks and make sure your thermometer hits one sixty five with juices clear
- Chill For Flavor:
- Pop the bowl or bag into the fridge for at least four hours. Overnight is even better if you want all the flavors to come alive
- Cover The Chicken:
- Get your thighs into a bag or a big bowl. Sprinkle on that rub. Toss and press them until everything's evenly coated
- Whip Up The Rub:
- Mix brown sugar, onion powder, chili powder, smoked paprika, garlic powder, oregano, salt, and red pepper flakes together in a bowl. Use a fork if you have clumps to break them up
Pin
Smoked paprika is hands down my favorite part here. Cracking open that jar takes me back to the good old days of lakeside grilling with family. There’s nothing like the way that smoky smell fills the air while the chicken cooks.
Keeping It Fresh
Pop leftover thighs in a tightly sealed container and keep in the fridge up to three days. For longer, freeze single portions and let thaw overnight before reheating. Warm gently in a covered pan so they don’t dry out.
Smart Swaps
If you’re out of brown sugar, drizzle in a little honey and mix it up. Can’t find smoked paprika? Any regular paprika will do. Want it spicier? Add a touch of cayenne or cut out the pepper flakes for less heat.
Tasty Pairings
Slice and toss over a leafy salad, stuff into pita with some cool tzatziki, or pair with summer classics like grilled corn or potato salad. If you’ve got extras, chop it up and roll into burritos for quick bites later.
Backstory
Saucy sweet-spicy grilled chicken pops up at cookouts all across the country. Dry rubs and smoky seasoning take a page from Southern cue traditions. The mix of sweet and heat is a crowd-pleaser for all ages.
Common Recipe Questions
- → What's an ideal chicken thigh marinade time?
Overnight is awesome if you've got time, but just 30 minutes is fine in a rush. Four hours is a sweet spot for big flavor.
- → Ways to get great grill marks on the chicken?
Keep your lid closed and use medium heat for around 6 to 8 minutes on each side. Always check for 165°F inside.
- → Is it okay to swap for bone-in thighs?
Definitely! Just bump up grilling time to let the bone heat through and hit the safe temp.
- → How hot is that rub, really?
It has a nice zing, but nothing too wild. Want it milder? Ease off on the chili powder or flakes.
- → How should I store and heat up leftovers?
Tuck leftovers in a sealed container in your fridge for up to three days. Warm them up slow so they stay juicy.