Pin
I stumbled on this Crunchy Mashed Potato Salad while trying to spice up my regular potato options. The mix of super crunchy spuds with a smooth zesty sauce has turned into my favorite dish to bring to gatherings. Folks always want me to share how I made it, and I can't help but smile when I see them take that first crispy bite.
The Magic Behind This Dish
What I love most about this salad is the contrast in textures. Those crunchy golden edges with the soft middle of each potato just keeps you coming back for more. I've thrown in my own spin with kewpie mayo and chopped pickles that add this incredible zing that you won't find in standard potato salad.
Picking Your Spuds
- Baby Potatoes: I always look for the smallest ones around since they crisp up wonderfully.
- Olive Oil: This isn't where you want to save money – good oil means better browning.
- Flavoring: Sea salt and freshly ground pepper really boost the taste.
Whipping Up That Tasty Sauce
- Kewpie Mayo: This is what makes it special – way more flavor than normal mayo.
- Raw Garlic: I chop it tiny for the strongest kick.
- Dijon Mustard: Just a bit gives it some heat.
- Chopped Pickles: They bring an awesome tangy snap.
- Shallots: Softer than onions but still adds great flavor.
- Herb-infused Yogurt: Makes everything taste fresh and lively.
Tools You'll Need
- Sturdy Baking Tray: My thick one gets those potatoes extra crunchy.
- Prep Bowls: I prefer clear ones to easily check what I'm working with.
- Iron Pan: Great for warming up any extras the next day.
Pin
First Steps
We start by cooking those potatoes. I watch them like a hawk because too soft and they'll just break apart. When you can stick a fork in but they still have some firmness, that's exactly what you want. After draining I wait until they're cool enough to touch.
Getting That Crunch
Here's where it gets good. I coat each potato with plenty of olive oil then push them down gently. Don't go too hard or they'll fall apart. Then they go into a hot oven until they turn golden and crispy all over.
Mixing The Sauce
While those potatoes are crisping up, I put my sauce together. All ingredients get stirred until smooth. The pickles and shallots go in at the end. I usually make more than needed because it tastes great on everything.
Putting It Together
After the potatoes reach peak crispiness, I let them sit briefly. You want them slightly cooled but still warm when the sauce goes on. I always keep some of the crunchiest pieces for the top – they work like little potato croutons.
Handy Hints
- Even Sizes: Try to keep potatoes roughly the same size so they cook together.
- Dry Them Well: Super dry potatoes turn out much crunchier.
- Added Crunch: I sometimes toss in crispy bacon pieces too.
Pin
Switch Things Up
- Try New Herbs: Switch herbs based on what you're serving it with.
- Crunch Factor: Some folks prefer super thin and extra crispy edges.
- Add Some Cheese: Grated parmesan before baking makes it amazing.
Prep Ahead Tricks
You can totally get this ready early. I often bake the potatoes and mix the sauce a day ahead. Just keep them apart and warm the potatoes in a pan to bring back that crunch before you mix them.
Avoid These Blunders
- Boiling Time: Soggy potatoes won't work well.
- Use Enough Oil: Don't skimp on oil – it's what makes them crunchy.
- Mix With Care: Add sauce right before serving to keep everything crisp.
Pro Moves
- Crunch Trick: A thin layer of cornstarch works wonders.
- Extra Sauce: Keep some sauce aside to pour on top.
- Heat It Up: I like adding a dash of smoky paprika sometimes.
Great Combos
This salad goes perfectly with anything off the grill. We enjoy it with BBQ or even as a fancy side with regular sandwiches. During summer it's fantastic with a cold brew or fizzy water and lemon.
Fast Facts
- Mayo Options: Normal works fine but kewpie brings something special.
- Top Potato Picks: Tiny yukons are my top choice but red potatoes do the job too.
- Storing Extras: Best when eaten within 24 hours.
Pin
Simple Solutions
- If Too Mushy: Mind your boiling time and cool them properly.
- Not Crunchy Enough: Try cooking at higher heat or a bit longer.
Clever Shortcuts
Don't forget to use parchment paper for quicker cleanup. I always cut potatoes into matching sizes and keep fresh herbs ready to sprinkle on top.
Finishing Moves
Just before I serve it, I give everything a last gentle mix. The crunchy parts on top make it look amazing and add such great texture with every bite.
What Makes It Special
This isn't your typical potato salad – it gets people talking. Whenever I make it, everyone hangs around the kitchen asking how I made it while sneaking tastes. It's become the dish I'm known for, and no wonder – that mix of crispy edges and creamy sauce is unbeatable.
Closing Thoughts
This dish takes a new spin on the usual potato salad. Roasted and smashed golden potatoes meet a creamy herb sauce, blending crunchy and smooth textures that taste incredible.
Common Recipe Questions
- → Can I prep this ahead of time?
- You can boil the potatoes and make the herb dressing earlier, but for the crunchiest potatoes, roast them right before eating.
- → Which potatoes should I pick?
- Opt for baby yellow or small new potatoes. Their thin skins and size make them ideal for smashing and roasting.
- → Could I swap out the yogurt?
- Sure, you can go with just mayo instead. The yogurt adds a light tanginess, but the dish is still yummy with only mayo.
- → Why aren’t my potatoes crunchy?
- Dry the boiled potatoes well and don’t crowd them on the pan. Spacing them out helps them crisp.
- → What pairs well with this?
- Grilled meat, burgers, sandwiches, or even barbecues go wonderfully with this dish. Great for picnics or casual dinners.