Pin
Juicy chicken thighs soaking up a spicy paprika sauce, they’re awesome for any summer cookout. Mixing smokey paprika, tender chicken, and just a bit of sweetness totally makes this dish a backyard favorite. Best part? You’ll be eating in under an hour. The smell always takes me back to those long summer nights outside, that whole smoky garlic vibe floating through the neighborhood.
I actually made this on a whim for a friend's barbecue and it was such a crowd-pleaser that now everyone requests it. My family's a little obsessed and every time I make it, it's like a mini summer vacation at home.
Ingredients
- Smoked paprika: Brings that signature smoky flavor and bold color, try to get Spanish if you can
- Brown sugar: Adds sweet caramel flavor and helps get those yummy grill marks, pick one with even grains
- Garlic powder: Mellow spice that’s perfect if fresh garlic is too strong
- Salt: Brings out all the flavors, coarse sea salt is best
- Black pepper: Adds a gentle heat, fresh cracked gives the most punch
- Chicken thighs: Boneless, skinless is juicy and tender, look for well-raised poultry
- Fresh garlic: Packs a punch for the marinade, always use fresh cloves over pre-chopped
- Olive oil: Gives the marinade its smooth texture, plus that sunny Mediterranean thing, go for extra virgin if possible
Step-by-Step Directions
- Let it rest and serve:
- Let your chicken chill a minute before you cut. This helps keep it extra juicy. Slice and eat while it’s warm.
- Finish cooking on indirect heat:
- Move the chicken to the cooler side of the grill. Let it go for another eight to ten minutes until cooked through. Check if the juices run clear or use a meat thermometer—you're looking for 165°F inside.
- Grill the chicken:
- Put the chicken straight onto the hot grate. Grill each side roughly four minutes till golden and crispy outside but juicy in the middle.
- Fire up the grill:
- Get your grill preheated to medium-high. Give the grates a quick oil rub so nothing sticks and you get pretty grill marks.
- Add marinade to chicken:
- Toss thighs in a large bowl or zip bag. Pour in the chopped fresh garlic and oil, then sprinkle on your spice mix. Get in there and mix so everything’s well coated. Cover and marinate in the fridge at least thirty minutes so the flavors can set in.
- Mix up the marinade:
- Stir together smoked paprika, brown sugar, garlic powder, salt and pepper in a little bowl. Make sure it’s all blended, this helps the flavor shine.
Pin
Heads Up
- Loaded with protein so it keeps you full and helps muscles
- Packed with flavor thanks to smoky paprika and fresh garlic
- You can prep early—marinade works even if made the day before
This always reminds me of chill summer nights with friends and that big splash of summer grill smells. My favorite time is when the sweet, tangy paprika sauce sizzles on cast iron and the color on the chicken pops. My kids always grab pieces straight from the grill before I even get it to the table.
Storage Hints
Seal and chill cooked chicken for up to three days. It’s great cold for lunches or a buffet, too. If you want to freeze some, let it cool first, freeze in portions, then thaw in the fridge and pop it in the oven for a quick warm up.
Swap It Up
If you’re out of brown sugar, swap in maple syrup for a fresh twist—still gets you that nice caramelized touch. Turkey steaks work instead of chicken thighs, just change your cook time a little. No smoked paprika? Go for regular sweet paprika powder and a pinch of smoked salt instead.
Pin
Serving Ideas
This chicken pairs awesome with a fresh Mediterranean salad or try some crispy baguette on the side. Roasted potatoes with a dash of paprika and olive oil are great, too. For a bright kick, squeeze a little lemon on the chicken and add a sprinkle of fresh herbs.
Background
Paprika’s a big deal in kitchens in Hungary and Spain, and gives lots of grilled dishes that punch. Here in Germany, grilling chicken with paprika is a go-to for summer get-togethers. Garlic and paprika is a classic match and always reminds people of holiday fun or family parties.
Common Recipe Questions
- → What kind of paprika should I use in the marinade?
Go for smoked paprika if you want a really rich, smoky flavor. If that's not your thing, sweet paprika works too.
- → How long do the chicken thighs need to marinate?
Pop them in the fridge for at least half an hour. If you leave them longer—say, a few hours—they soak up more taste.
- → How do I know when the chicken is done?
The chicken’s good to go when its center hits 74°C and the juice turns clear if you poke it.
- → Can I use this marinade for other meats?
Yep, try it with turkey, pork, or even toss it with veggies for grilling—works like a charm.
- → What goes well on the side with grilled chicken thighs?
Crunchy roasted potatoes, crisp salad, or crusty bread all make a tasty match.
- → Do the chicken thighs have to have skin on?
Nope, skinless thighs still end up juicy and packed with flavor thanks to the marinade.