Pin
This tangy dill pickle pasta salad is loaded with bold flavor and a creamy, crave-worthy dressing. Twisty rotini pasta grabs hold of every bit of sauce, while bite-sized pieces of crisp pickles give you zesty pops in every forkful. Mellow Colby Jack cubes mellow out the sharpness, and a hit of both fresh dill and punchy pickle juice kicks the dill vibes way up. Throw in some chopped white onion for subtle crunch and aroma so nothing gets lost. You’ll want to make this for every summer hangout—it always gets everyone talking and is just plain fun to eat.
This version exists because I got tired of bland salads that promised pickles but barely delivered. If you, like me, eat pickles straight from the jar, you'll appreciate that this mix doesn’t hold back. I put two full cups of diced pickles in and a hefty pour of pickle juice right in the dressing for a big wallop of flavor. The very first time I shared it, people kept asking for the how-to before dinner finished, and even my husband—who’s usually meh about pickles—quietly snagged seconds.
Ultimate Ingredients
- Rotini pasta (8 oz): Those curly noodles trap all the creamy sauce so every bite pops
- Baby dill pickles (2 cups, diced): Plenty of juicy crunch with loads of tang
- Colby Jack cheese (1 cup, small dice): Smooths things out with creamy, mellow flavor
- White onion (¼ cup, finely diced): Gets in there for a gentle bite but never takes over
- Garlic powder (½ teaspoon): Adds a touch of savoriness without smacking you over the head
- Sour cream (¼ cup): Creamy tang that works perfectly with the pickle zip
- Dill pickle juice (3 tablespoons): Doubles down on that briny hit and keeps the dressing smooth
- Fresh dill (2 tablespoons, chopped): Bright, herby flavor scattered throughout
- Real mayonnaise (¾ cup): Creamy base that makes everything velvety
- Salt and pepper (to taste): Pulls all the flavors together
Salad Build
Pasta Game Plan
Start your rotini in a big pot of salty water. Give it just a nudge past al dente—aim for 8 or 9 minutes—since chilling firms it up. Rinse it under cold water fast to stop the cooking and prevent sticking, then shake the colander well so it’s not watery (nobody likes a watered-down dressing). Give your pasta plenty of time to dry out for the best texture later on.
Pickle Prep
Go for those baby dills—they’re crunchier and loaded with flavor. Dice them into even, small pieces around a quarter inch so you get a snack of pickle in every bite but not a mouthful. Before tossing them in, lay the diced pickles on paper towels and pat them dry. This keeps your salad from getting runny and keeps the dressing thick and creamy.
Dressing Action
Whisk together mayonnaise and sour cream in a big bowl until there are no lumps. Slowly stir in the pickle juice so everything stays silky. Sprinkle in chopped dill, garlic powder, salt, and pepper—mix until it’s flecked with green and smooth but not too thick. This guarantees the salad won’t dry out and every spiral of pasta gets coated just right.
Smooth Mixing
Drop the drained pasta straight into the bowl with the dressing. Gently fold so every bit is lightly covered. Next, scatter in the pickles, onions, and diced cheese, giving it all a soft mix to spread things evenly. Chop the cheese a bit smaller than the pickles so it balances instead of grabbing all the attention. Keep folding carefully so every bite tastes just as good as the last.
Chill For Flavor
Scoop your finished salad into a serving dish and cover tightly with plastic wrap. Let it hang out in the fridge for at least an hour (two is even better). That rest time lets everything mingle, so the flavors become even more intense and the pasta soaks up more of the dressing. If you’re making it way ahead, stash a little dressing aside to stir in later so the salad doesn’t dry out—fixes it right up before you serve.
Serving Tips
Take the salad out about 15 minutes before you want to eat—it tastes better if it’s not fridge-cold. Give it a gentle toss to perk everything up. If it seems a little dry, pour in a splash more pickle juice or some saved dressing. A pinch of chopped dill and a couple pickle slices on top look great and show off the flavors hiding inside. Use a roomy bowl for easy serving and to show off all that color.
Pin
My grandma always told me, “Do it right or just don't do it.” That’s how I treat this pasta salad. It doesn’t just give you a whiff of pickle—every bite delivers plenty. The first time at a family get-together, my aunt (a total pickle superfan) called it "the only pasta salad worth picking." Now, whenever I bring it, even the usual salad-skippers grab seconds and thirds. There’s no mistaking it on the potluck table—it’s the bowl that empties first and always has folks chatting about the pickles.
How To Enjoy
This pasta salad is awesome next to hot dogs and burgers for a summer BBQ. It’s also spot-on with pulled pork or smoked brisket when you want something tangy to balance the richness. Throw it on a plate with crispy fried chicken—it cools things down and brings a fresh punch. Or go lighter and serve a scoop with some tomato soup—sort of like grilled cheese and pickles, but even better together!
Fun Twists
Switch things up using bread and butter pickles if you want it sweeter, or toss in spicy pickles if you crave some heat. Add chopped ham or turkey for more filling power and a main-course spin. Want a Mediterranean feel? Swap pickles for kalamata olives, use feta, and stir in roasted red peppers. Stir a little ranch seasoning into the dressing for a tangy change-up. If you can’t get enough pickles, mix in a tablespoon of pickle relish for extra punch.
Storing Leftovers
Keep leftovers in an airtight container in the fridge for up to three days. The pasta will soak up the dressing, so it can dry out a bit. Just refresh it with a bit more mayo mixed with pickle juice and you’re good. Freezing isn’t a good idea—the dressing will just break up. If you want to prep ahead, store the dressing and everything else separately, then combine a couple hours before eating for the freshest texture.
I’ve whipped up a lot of pasta salads, but this one packed with pickles is the real star. There’s nothing like seeing people light up over a bold dish that showcases its main flavor. While plenty of salad bowls fade into the background, this one grabs attention, sparks that classic “what’s in this?” chatter, and always gets refilled. Sometimes making your own favorites wins out over tradition—especially if you’re all about pickles. If you’ve ever wanted a pasta salad that doesn’t hold back on dill, this is it.
Pin
Common Recipe Questions
- → How early can I prep this salad?
- For yummiest texture, try to serve within a few hours of mixing. It keeps fine in the fridge, but don’t forget the sauce gets thicker and less smooth the longer it sits.
- → What’s the best kind of pickles to use?
- Tiny baby dills are super easy to dice up and work best, but use whatever dill pickles you’ve got. Just chop them small, so you don’t get big bites.
- → Can I grab a different pasta?
- Absolutely, any pasta shape will do, but rotini curls scoop up the creamy sauce the best compared to straighter noodles.
- → How do I give this some kick?
- Stir in cayenne pepper bit by bit until you get the heat level you like. It pairs really well with that pickle zing.
- → Can I swap Colby Jack cheese?
- Go for cheddar, pepper jack, or monterey jack—just don’t pick a soft, crumbly cheese. Cube something that holds together.